Category: Uncategorized

Episode 49: 1945 The Bloodbath


Ted Whitten said it was the best game he ever saw, several of the players had no memory of what happened, a suspended player got reported and Ted Whitfield’s pre-match routine was to drink 6 beers with a top up at halftime. The Bloodbath was an extraordinary Grand Final played shortly  after the end of World War II where a football match occasionally broke out between the fights. 1945 was a pivotal year, supporters were back watching footy and the country waited for the end of hostilities, mourned the death of the US president and an Australian Prime Minister then saw the dawn of the Atomic Era. Listen to the episode to see how the 1945 season unfolded and how the legend of the Bloodbath began.

Tribunal Findings

The VFL tribunal heard the charges on Tuesday 2 October, and made the following findings

Ted Whitfield (South Melbourne): Suspended until 31 December 1946 for his incident with goal umpire Les Whyte in the final quarter, in which he used abusive language, then attempted to strike Whyte, then ran down the field and lifted his guernsey to try to avoid being reported. Whitfield was also suspended for two weeks for time-wasting by kicking the ball away after a free kick.
Jack Williams (South Melbourne): Suspended for twelve weeks: eight weeks for fighting with Rod McLean, and four weeks for using abusive language towards the umpires.
Don Grossman (South Melbourne): Suspended for eight weeks for striking Jim Mooring.
Jim Cleary (South Melbourne): Suspended for eight weeks for striking Ken Hands; but was cleared of a further charge of attempting to strike Bob Chitty.
Bob Chitty (Carlton: Suspended for eight weeks for elbowing Bill Williams.
Ron Savage (Carlton): Suspended for eight weeks for striking Don Grossman.
Herbie Matthews (South Melbourne): Severely reprimanded for time-wasting by throwing the ball away after a free kick.
Only Ken Hands (Carlton) and Keith Smith (South Melbourne) were found not guilty of their charges.

The Bloodbath

Book by Ian Shaw. Out of print now so may be difficult to get a new copy.

Episode 48: 1944 Up the Junction


Supporters were “Up the Junction” in 1944, making their way to the Junction Oval, hosting the Grand Final for the first time since 1899, baked by hot winds on a 30C day with trams and busses on strike. It had been another tough wartime season, so tough even Jack Dyer got suspended, for the only time in his career. Some had suggested that anyone who hit Dyer deserved a Victoria Cross. The Tigers had considered a boycott in protest against a team mates suspension but were in their third Grand Final in a row against Fitzroy, back in the Grand Final 22 years after their last premiership. As the Allies progressed through Europe and the Pacific, football administrators grappled with the future of football, would their be peace in our time between the VFL and the VFA?

Episode 47: 1943 The Earliest Wooden Spoon Ever


Eleven teams started the 1943 season but only ten made it to the final round. To ensure only one bye per team, the club on the bottom of the ladder after round eleven was eliminated! The earliest Wooden Spoon ever! The war meant everything was different, US Marines were at the MCG, they even played a gridiron game, the American football code as a rare game on the G once it was occupied for the war. The Americans even took on the Australians in a hybrid football game described as ‘aerial bombardment”. All the while the VFL season unfolded, with challenges of player availability and news of loss at the front line. Still plans were being prepared for peace time, would the VFL be expanding?

Episode 46A: The Changi Brownlow


This episode delves into a unique chapter of football history set against the backdrop of World War II. Discover the remarkable story of the Changi Australian Football Association and the creation of the Changi Brownlow Medal within the brutal confines of Changi Prisoner of War Camp in Singapore. Despite being far from home in a hostile environment, Australian POWs found solace and a sense of normalcy through a makeshift football league. Learn how this extraordinary season symbolised the enduring spirit and camaraderie of the players amidst adversity, and how it left an indelible mark on the history of the sport. With insights from Roland Perry’s book, “The Changi Brownlow,” and historical records this is a story that honours the legacy of resilience of the prisoners at Changi and the unifying power of the Australian Game.

The Victorian and Rest of Australia teams in the final game played at Changi

The teams below were sourced from a facebook post by Bat Robertson who sourced it from the Boyles Football Photos website which, sadly, is no longer available (http://www.boylesfootballphotos.net.au/article87–Changi…). I can’t vouch for its absolute authenticity but I have been able to identify additional information on a number of the players listed that confirms they were at Changi and some of their football history. I have included links where available. If you have any additional information on the players named below please contact me at info@grandfinalhistory.au. The men who played in this unique match, and the season that preceded it, deserve every recognition

Victorian TeamRest of Australia Team
K. Bell (Stony Creek)Brookes (City Launceston, Tasmania)
L. H. Green (Mentone)G. B, Kenney – East Fremantle
Alan Goulden (South Melbourne Districts)Robert Broadbent – Glenelg
Perkins (Mortlake)
Lou Daily Subiaco, Collingwood Geelong
Hancock (Mildura)Goulter (Clair Association, South Australia),
Crisp (Seal Lake)Clarke (Country League, Western Australia),
John Mahony -Collingwood Reserves 18 Games, 20 Goals 1936-37Spackman (Goldfields, Western Australia)
T. Baker (Essendon Reserves)Joe Pearce – Swan Districts
Bob Small (Echuca)Curnow (Port Lincoln, South Australia),
Sparkes (Melbourne Juniors)White (Hill Association, South Australia),
McGrath (Riverina)Williams (Wembley Association, Western Australia)
Bobby Mullinger – South Melbourne 6 Games, 1 Goal 1939-40 & 1946Hutton (South Country League, Tasmania)
Halloran (St Kilda & Brighton)McAllister (Mt Hawthorn Assn. WA)
T. Joyce (Kew Districts)Manton (Tatura Assn. , SA)
Robinson (Geelong Reserves)Smith (East Fremantle)
Byrne (Abbotsford)Pearsal, Thomas Gordon (Lefroy)
John “Jack” Haig (East Coburg)
Peter Chitty (St Kilda)
Umpire: Wilfred “Chicken” Smallhorn
Emergency Umpire: Roy Charles Fox

Episode 46: 1942 Americanising the City and the Game

The Americans were taking over the city and were amazed by the footy and yet some wanted to Americanise the local game to help it expand north and internationally. But there were bigger problems north of Australia with the Japanese advancing through the Pacific.

Not all the teams played, the MCG was a not so secret military base and Sunday football became a regular event but not for the VFL. The ordinary way of life was gone, the government was taking everyone’s binoculars but footy provided some comfort and normality in a season like no other.

Episode 45: 1941 A Greater Job Than Football


A world in turmoil, a world at war, radio broadcasts blocked by solar storms and some want to play football on Sundays, undermining the nation’s spiritual and moral foundations and risking national destruction, there was a lot going on in 1941. Melbourne were aiming for their third premiership in a row while others wondered if football should be played at all. The VFA were stealing star players while others were in military camps, unsure how many games they would play and some were paying the ultimate price.

Episode 44: The Greatest Shirtfront Ever


The greatest shirtfront ever delivered occurred in possibly the toughest season ever, with more players reported in 1940 than ever before. The drama and shocks on the field were matched by the turmoil and challenges off the field as the VFA looked to recruit the biggest stars of the day and many players made the biggest decisions of their lives to enlist in the armed services. St Kilda won their first premiership (The Patriotic Premiership with a Flag and a Cup) while Jack Dyer and Norm Smith clashed on the MCG. It was a year unlike any other with a season unlike any other, the 1940 VFL season.

Jack Dyer describes the 1940 Grand Final with Stephen Phillips. Thanks to Rhettorspective YouTube channel

Dan Minogue also had his photo turned to the wall when he left Collingwood, just like Ron Todd. Here is the story of the Minogue Photo

The Patriotic Premiership was St Kilda’s first premiership in the VFL. It was a fundraiser lightning premiership held on the 3rd of August 1940. The video below shows a short summary of the game with a Jack Dyer “Don’t Argue” at the 23 second mark!

Some photos from the Patriotic Premiership

Episode 43: 1939 My Melancholy Duty


War declared in Europe and the battle between the VFL and VFA continues with an 18 year old star getting the biggest financial offer ever made to an Australian footballer, would he stay or would he go? Batman, Angry Anderson and the Sydney Olympics, they are all connected and the trail goes back to 1939. There was turmoil at Collingwood, new rules to absorb and a year that saw a turnover in the final four. All this and more in this episode of Grand Final History.


Episode 42: 1938 Throwing the Ball


The VFL was “The rebellious child of the Association” and it could not dictate how football was going to be played in 1938. There was a split in Australian Football, the Association were changing the rules, allowing throwing the ball and more as they looked to attract more spectators to their games, so “Who cares what the League thinks” was their motto. 1938 was a dramatic year on and off the field, bribery attempts by gambling cartels, new teams in the finals and doping to help win a grand final. All this and more in the latest episode of Grand Final History.

Episode 41: 1937 The Greatest Game of All

The greatest game of all they called it: The 1937 Grand Final between Collingwood and Geelong. The year saw a King’s coronation, with a North Melbourne player representing the VFL in London and Fitzroy became the Gorillas! Finals prices increased, never popular, yet a record crowd was a the Grand Final. It was the Magpies chance for a premiership hat trick and to send Gordon Coventry off in style or Geelong’s opportunity to give Reg Hickey a premiership in his second stint as captain coach. Meanwhile, trouble was brewing with the VFA.

At the 1937 Carnival triple Brownlow medallist Haydn Bunton did a radio interview that was recorded and now restored. Here it here